December 17, 2025
2 Comments

Which 3 Movies Got 17 Oscars? The Real Oscar Winners Revealed

Advertisements

So, you typed "which 3 movies got 17 Oscars" into Google, huh? I've been there. It's one of those questions that pops up in movie trivia nights or when you're arguing with friends about film history. But here's the thing: if you're expecting to find three films that each bagged 17 Academy Awards, I've got some news for you. It's a myth. A big one. No movie has ever won 17 Oscars in a single ceremony or overall. The real maximum is 11, and only three movies have hit that number. Yeah, it's a letdown if you believed the 17 story, but stick with me—this is way more interesting.

I remember first hearing about this from a buddy who swore up and down that some old classic had 17 wins. I spent hours digging through Oscar databases, and guess what? He was wrong. The Academy Awards started back in 1929, and over the decades, the most any film has taken home is 11 statues. Why does the 17 number keep floating around? Maybe it's a mix-up with total nominations or just internet folklore. But let's get into the facts.

The Actual Oscar Record-Holders: No 17 in Sight

When people ask "which 3 movies got 17 Oscars," they're probably thinking of the top winners. But the truth is, the trio that dominates the record books are Titanic (1997), The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003), and Ben-Hur (1959). Each won 11 Oscars, not 17. That's the ceiling. I know, it's less glamorous, but it's real. Here's a quick table to lay it out clearly.

Movie TitleYearNumber of Oscars WonKey Categories
Titanic199711Best Picture, Director, Visual Effects
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King200311Best Picture, Director, Adapted Screenplay
Ben-Hur195911Best Picture, Director, Actor

Seeing this, you might wonder why 17 is such a persistent idea. I think it's because people confuse total nominations with wins. For example, All About Eve (1950) had 14 nominations but only won 6 Oscars. Or maybe it's just a number that sounds impressive and stuck in pop culture. Whatever the reason, the question of which 3 movies got 17 Oscars is based on a misunderstanding.

Breaking Down the Real 11-Oscar Winners

Titanic: The Blockbuster That Swept the Awards

Alright, let's talk about Titanic. James Cameron's epic romance-disaster film was a phenomenon. When it hit the Oscars in 1998, it tied the record with 11 wins. I was a kid then, and everyone was obsessed with that movie. It won everything from Best Picture to Best Original Song for "My Heart Will Go On." But 17? Nope. The film had 14 nominations, so maybe that's where the confusion starts. If you're searching for which 3 movies got 17 Oscars, Titanic often comes up, but it's firmly in the 11 club.

What's interesting is how Titanic dominated technical categories like Visual Effects and Sound, showing how big-budget films can clean up. But even with all that glory, it didn't come close to 17. Personally, I think the movie's impact overshadows the actual count—people remember the hype, not the numbers.

The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King: A Fantasy Triumph

Then there's The Return of the King. Peter Jackson's finale to the LOTR trilogy was a critical darling, winning all 11 Oscars it was nominated for. That's a perfect sweep! I binge-watched the extended editions last year, and it's still stunning. But again, when folks ask which 3 movies got 17 Oscars, this one gets mentioned erroneously. It won categories like Best Picture and Director, but 17 would be fantasy in more ways than one.

Some fans argue it deserved even more, but the Academy doesn't work that way. The film's success helped fantasy genres gain respect, yet the Oscar count is solidly 11. If you're digging into which movies won 17 Oscars, you'll hit a dead end here.

Ben-Hur: The Classic Epic

Ben-Hur is the old-timer in this group. Released in 1959, it set the record with 11 wins that stood for decades. The chariot race scene alone is iconic. But no, it didn't win 17. I watched it recently, and while it's a masterpiece, the Oscar tally is historical, not mythical. The question of which 3 movies got 17 Oscars might stem from its legendary status, but the facts are clear.

This film swept major awards, including Best Actor for Charlton Heston, but like the others, it's part of the 11-win club. It's funny how time inflates stories—maybe in another 50 years, people will say it won 20!

Why the Myth of 17 Oscars Persists

So, why does everyone seem to think there are movies with 17 Oscars? I've seen this question pop up on forums and in YouTube comments. Part of it is misinformation. Some websites or social media posts might throw out big numbers for clicks. Also, people mix up terms: "Oscars" versus "nominations." For instance, La La Land had 14 nominations in 2017 but only won 6. That gap can lead to confusion.

Another thing: the Academy Awards have categories that change over time. In the early days, there were fewer awards, so winning 17 would be impossible. Today, with around 24 categories, it's theoretically possible but hasn't happened. I think the idea of which 3 movies got 17 Oscars is just a catchy bit of trivia that got distorted. When I first heard it, I almost believed it too—it sounds so specific!

Here's a quick list of movies with high nomination counts that might fuel the myth:

  • All About Eve (1950): 14 nominations, 6 wins
  • Titanic (1997): 14 nominations, 11 wins
  • La La Land (2016): 14 nominations, 6 wins

See? Nominations don't equal wins. That's probably where the 17 idea comes from.

Other Movies That Came Close (But Not to 17)

If you're curious about films that nearly hit the record, there are a few. West Side Story (1961) won 10 Oscars, and The English Patient (1996) won 9. But none break the 11 barrier. When you're looking into which 3 movies got 17 Oscars, it's worth noting that even the second-place films are far off. I kind of wish there was a movie with 17—it'd make for a better story—but reality is what it is.

Here's a table of runners-up:

MovieYearOscars Won
West Side Story196110
The English Patient19969
Gigi19589

These are great films, but they don't solve the puzzle of which 3 movies got 17 Oscars. It's a ghost hunt.

Common Questions About Oscar Wins

Q: Is there any movie that won Oscars in every category it was nominated for?
A: Yes, The Return of the King won all 11 Oscars it was nominated for, which is rare. But that's still not 17!

Q: Why do people keep asking which 3 movies got 17 Oscars?
A: Probably because it's a round number that sounds impressive. In my experience, misinformation spreads fast online. I've had to correct friends on this multiple times.

Q: Could a movie ever win 17 Oscars in the future?
A: Technically, yes, since there are about 24 categories now. But it's unlikely because votes get split. The Academy tends to spread the love. So, the query of which 3 movies got 17 Oscars might remain unanswered forever.

My Take on the Oscar Hype

I've always been a movie buff, and awards season is my Super Bowl. But the obsession with numbers like 17 Oscars feels a bit silly. Who cares if a film wins 11 or 17? It's about the art. That said, I get why people are curious—it's fun to debate. When I first researched which 3 movies got 17 Oscars, I was disappointed to find it was a bust. But learning the real stories behind Titanic and Ben-Hur was way cooler.

On the negative side, some film snobs use these stats to put down modern movies. Like, "Oh, that new blockbuster only won 3 Oscars, it's trash." But that's missing the point. Awards are subjective. The question of which movies won 17 Oscars is a red herring—it's the films that matter.

Wrapping Up: The Bottom Line on Oscar Records

To sum it up, if you're searching for which 3 movies got 17 Oscars, you won't find them. The real champions are Titanic, The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, and Ben-Hur, each with 11 wins. The myth of 17 likely comes from confusion over nominations or internet myths. I hope this clears things up. Next time someone brings it up, you can set the record straight.

And remember, while which 3 movies got 17 Oscars is a dead end, the true stories of these Oscar winners are full of drama and achievement. Maybe that's more valuable than a big number.